Yet Another EBRI Miscalculation on Social Security

November 12, 1998

This morning, the Employee Benefit Research Institute (EBRI) will release yet another in a series of studies describing supposed logistic obstacles to privatizing Social Security. This one will discuss administrative costs and related issues. If you see the EBRI study, you'll want to consider these observations from the Cato Institute's director of health and welfare studies, Michael Tanner:

"Will it cost more to administer a privatized Social Security system than the current program? Very likely. A Mercedes Benz costs more than a Ford Pinto. The important question is which system will give seniors a more secure retirement. A privatized system clearly does that.

"In 1935, when the Social Security system was developed, only 20 percent of American households had telephones, few had televisions and none had computers, but the federal government managed to administer the new program. It is impossible to anticipate the technology of the future. EBRI's assumptions are based on an unrealistically pessimistic prediction of future capability.

"Moreover, EBRI clearly overstates the cost of administering a privatized system. A forthcoming Cato study by Robert Genetski, former chief economist at Harris Bank and now director of resources and asset management at Chicago Capital, will show that administrative costs in a privatized system will likely be less than $20 per person per year."

2001 Index | 2000 Index | 1999 Index | 1998 Index





Printer Friendly Version


  Quick Facts Archive  
  The maximum original Social Security tax was just $60. Today it is $11,000.
[Details...]
 
Research Corner
 

BROWSE BY TOPIC

Social Security's Financial Crisis
Rate of Return Issues
Women, Minorities, and the Poor
Other Reasons for Social Security Reform
Government Investment of Social Security
Social Security Reform Plans
International Pension Reform
Transition Financing
Problems and Criticisms
Public Opinion and Polling

BROWSE BY AUTHOR Go

BROWSE BY TYPE Go

 
 

"The push to convert Social Security into a system of personal accounts has been led by the Cato Institute."

- Paul Krugman
New York Times
September 6, 2002